Health Care Reform Looks to be in Trouble as One-Man Supreme Court Left to Decide Fate of Obamacare

Health Care Reform Looks to be in Trouble as One-Man Supreme Court Left to Decide Fate of Obamacare

You know when you and eight friends want to go to dinner, and four want to go to that one place, and four would prefer the other? Even worse is when they turn to you and say, “Well, it’s up to you.” Now just imagine those friends are all Supreme Court justices and they’ve just handed you the task of being the decisive vote on the fate of health care reform. That’s how it must feel to be Justice Anthony Kennedy every single day.

As with many high-profile cases over the years, the post-arguments analysis coming from the U.S. Supreme Court today is that Kennedy will once again be the deciding vote on the fate of Obamacare. Where he stands after today’s session remains a matter of debate, though.

NBC’s Pete Williams and CNN’s Jeffrey Toobin seem to think that the court will find the individual mandate to be unconstitutional, while SCOTUSblog’s Lyle Denniston thinks that while it is certainly Kennedy’s call to make, the issue hasn’t yet been decided. “Expecting the demise of the mandate seemed decidedly premature,” wrote Denniston this afternoon. (Toobin sees no gray area here: “This law looks like it’s going to be struck down,” he said.)

Most reports coming from the court indicate that Samuel Alito and Antonin Scalia played the role of predictable critics of the government’s case, arguing that if Americans are forced to buy health insurance, little would stop future mandates on everything from cell phones to broccoli and burial services. (Yes, those were all mentioned.) The four liberal judges seemed sympathetic to Obama’s health care reform, while Clarence Thomas again maintained his monk-like silence during court sessions. (Audio and transcripts of all the arguments from today are available here.)

What many seem to agree on is that Solicitor General Donald B. Verrilli Jr. didn’t make the case in a particularly convincing fashion:

Today was the second of three days of arguments in the Supreme Court. Tomorrow the court takes up the next logical concern-can Obamacare survive if the individual mandate is found to be unconstitutional? Decisions are expected in June.

Check out the original post over at DCist

Health Care Reform Looks to be in Trouble as One-Man Supreme Court Left to Decide Fate of Obamacare

Thanks for subscribing to the CTayLee.com RSS Feed! Let's connect on Facebook and Twitter.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Links:oakley sunglasses outletoakley sunglasses outletBeats By Drecheap beats by dreCheap Beats By Drecheap beats by drelouis vuitton outletlouis vuitton outletlouis vuitton outletray ban sunglasses outletcheap beats by drecheap beats by drecheap beats by drecheap beats by drecheap beats by drecheap beats by drecheap beats by drecheap beats by dreray ban sunglasses outletray ban sunglasses outletray ban sunglasses outletray ban sunglasses outletoakley sunglasses outletoakley sunglasses outletoakley sunglasses outletChristian louboutin outletChristian louboutin outletChristian louboutin outletChristian louboutin outletlouis vuitton outletlouis vuitton outlet
hermes belt
cheap ralph lauren polo shirts cheap ralph lauren polo polo ralph lauren factory store ralph lauren polo
Read previous post:
How To Set Up Galaxy S2′s WI-FI Hotspot Feature

Galaxy S2 was one of most popular android phone of the year 2011. When it was released it had everything...

Close
Links:louis vuitton